Out With The Old, In With The Accurate – Looking Beyond Google Analytics
For years, Google Analytics has been the backbone of how we understand website performance – tracking patient visits, form submissions, and campaign success. It’s familiar, powerful, and free.
But lately, we’ve been asking ourselves: are there better-suited tools out there? Tools that don’t just report data, but empower us, and you, to make clearer and more effective marketing decisions.
Why Question Google Analytics Now?
Relying exclusively on Google Analytics means depending on a tool that, while widely used, comes with trade-offs. With increasing concerns around data privacy, ownership, sampling, and regulatory compliance, it’s worth exploring whether a different analytics solution might better serve your dental practice – especially when the data we pull directly influences your marketing strategy.
Without truly reliable and transparent data, how confident can you be in the decisions you make about patient acquisition, budget allocation, or content strategy?
Google Analytics vs. Matomo: What’s the Difference?
One of the strongest alternatives to Google Analytics is Matomo, an open-source analytics platform that offers a very different philosophy when it comes to data.
Here are some key differences:
- Data Ownership & Control
With Google Analytics, your data is stored on Google’s servers. Matomo, by contrast, allows 100% data ownership – you control where and how your data is stored. - Privacy & Compliance
Matomo is built with privacy in mind. It supports features such as IP anonymisation, first-party cookies, and even cookieless tracking. Because you own the data, there’s less risk of third-party sharing, helping with compliance with regulations like GDPR. - Accuracy of Data
One of the biggest issues with Google Analytics is data sampling: when your site has high traffic or complex reporting, GA may only analyse a subset of data to produce reports. Matomo, on the other hand, offers unsampled data, so you’re making decisions based on the full picture. - No Data Limits
With Matomo (especially self-hosted), there are no hard limits on how much data you can collect, unlike Google Analytics, which can limit data based on the plan. - Advanced Behavioural Insights
Matomo isn’t just pageviews. It supports heatmaps, session recordings, form analytics, and more – giving you deeper insight into how visitors (potential patients) interact with your website. - Open-Source & Customisable
Because Matomo is open source, it’s highly customisable. You can build or add plugins, adapt the platform to your needs, and interrogate the underlying data more freely.
Why This Matters for Dental Marketing
In a dental marketing context, the stakes for accurate data are high:
- Patient Acquisition: Without clear analytics, you might misunderstand which channels (e.g. Google Ads, social media, organic search) are driving real patient enquiries.
- Budget Allocation: If sampling or data limits skew your reports, you risk over-investing in underperforming campaigns and underfunding high-conversion ones.
- User Experience Optimisation: Tools like heatmaps and session recordings allow us to see how prospective patients navigate your site – where they drop off, which CTAs they ignore, and which forms could be simplified to boost conversions.
- Trust & Transparency: With data stored under your control, you have full transparency over patient behavioural data. That builds trust – both with your team and your patients.
- Regulatory Confidence: In regions with strict data protection laws, owning your analytics data and minimising third-party exposure reduces risk and helps maintain compliance.
Making Decisions Without Clear Data – The Risk
Relying on incomplete, sampled, or opaque data hampers the ability to make effective marketing decisions. It’s like trying to steer a ship based on a partial map: you might be headed in the right direction, but you’re not fully informed, and that can cost time, money, and missed opportunities.
For dental practices, this could mean:
- Overlooking which services (e.g. cosmetic dentistry, orthodontics) truly generate high-quality leads
- Misallocating ad spend on underperforming campaigns
- Failing to improve the patient journey on your website because you don’t understand drop-off points
- Making decisions based on assumptions, not data you trust
So, What Do We Do About It?
At Dental Design, we’re constantly evaluating and testing new tools that help us deliver better insights and results for our clients. Google Analytics still has its place – it’s powerful, familiar, and integrated into many workflows – but we believe in staying ahead of the curve.
That’s why we’re experimenting with Matomo, among other analytics solutions. We’re comparing:
- How data accuracy improves (especially for high-traffic sites)
- The added value of behavioural analytics (heatmaps, session recordings)
- How data ownership and privacy features can give our clients more control
- The potential ROI uplift when decisions are based on richer, more reliable data
We’ve long relied on Google Analytics because it’s a trusted, robust standard – but just because something is standard doesn’t mean it’s the best tool for you. As a dental marketing agency, our priority is to use the tools that deliver the clearest, most actionable insights – helping you make confident decisions about patient acquisition, website optimisation, and marketing strategy.
We’re not saying every practice needs to switch – but we do think it’s healthy to ask: are we settling for “good enough”? Or can we aim for better?
We’ll continue to research and test the next generation of marketing tools so that you don’t have to. Our goal is always to help you achieve your marketing ambitions with clarity, confidence, and control.
More posts from our team
Five Star
Reviewed Marketing
"Would definitely recommend to a friend"
"I cannot recommend Dental Design highly enough"
"Really great company to deal with"
"Very professional, efficient & adaptive to new situations"
"I cannot recommend them highly enough"
"Has been invaluable and gone out of her way to help us"
"We love the look of our practice website. Very professional!"
"Dental Design stood out both in their knowledge of the industry and their professionalism"
"The team and package offered at dental design was unrivalled"
"absolutely fantastic and are always on hand to help"
"Dental Design are fantastic to work with"
"always met with a swift and professional response"
